© Unreal Engine
- Fortnight In The App Store
- Fortnite The Application Has Crashed
- Fortnite The App Store
- Fortnite The App Download
- Fortnite The Application Has Crashed
Apple will not have to reinstate Fortnite to its app store, at least for now, a federal judge ruled Monday night in a historic legal battle between the iPhone maker and the producer of one of the world's most popular video games.
The decision means Fortnite players on Apple devices likely won't get access to the game's newest season content, which launches Aug. 27 and requires an update to the game that Apple will not allow onto the app store.
But Fortnite's creator, Epic Games, won what may be a more significant — albeit temporary — respite on Monday that could have ripple effects across the digital media industry.
The Action Building game where you team up with other players to build massive forts and battle against hordes of monsters, all while crafting and looting in giant worlds where no two games are ever the same. Apple kicked Fortnite off the App Store for breaking its rules, and Epic responded with a civil lawsuit against Apple, alleging that Apple was violating antitrust law. In case you didn't notice, Fortnite, arguably the most popular game in the world, has been removed from the App Store and Play Store. This was because of a dispute that started between Epic Games and Apple. This issue caused Apple to delete Fortnite from the App Store, making it impossible to find or download Fortnite on iPhone or iPad. Fortnite maker Epic Games sent shockwaves through the tech industry this week when it sued Apple and Google, claiming both companies' app stores are monopolies. If Epic were to win the lawsuits.
Under a temporary restraining order issued by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, Apple must not block Unreal Engine, a major game development software suite owned by Epic, from its app store. Epic declined to comment.
In a statement Tuesday, Apple reiterated its claim that Fortnite's ban could be resolved by Epic itself.
'We agree with Judge Rogers that 'the sensible way to proceed' is for Epic to comply with the App Store guidelines and continue to operate while the case proceeds,' Apple said. 'If Epic takes the steps the judge has recommended, we will gladly welcome Fortnite back onto iOS. We look forward to making our case to the court in September.'
The order resolves what had become a growing concern over the future of video games, film and television ever since Apple and Epic went to court earlier this month.
Unreal Engine is a major design platform used to create lifelike and ultra-realistic computer-generated scenes. It's played a central role in video games including PlayerUnknown's 'Battlegrounds' and 'Borderlands 3,' and has provided the backdrops in TV shows such as Disney's 'The Mandalorian.'
Last week, Apple told Epic that it planned to revoke its ability to distribute the Unreal Engine software on the Apple app store, not merely block players' access to Fortnite.
If Apple were to follow through on its plan, it could hinder developers, film producers and others from getting a critical tool onto Apple devices to create apps and entertainment for consumers, Epic and other developers argued. To bolster its case, Epic submitted a sworn declaration from Microsoft claiming that Apple's plan 'will harm game creators and gamers.'
On Monday, the judge agreed.
If Apple followed through on its Unreal ban, it would lead to 'potential significant damage to both the Unreal Engine platform itself, and to the gaming industry generally, including on both third-party developers and gamers,' Gonzalez Rogers wrote in her order. 'Epic Games and Apple are at liberty to litigate against each other, but their dispute should not create havoc to bystanders.'
The order comes amid a wider legal claim by Epic that Apple's practice of taking a 30% cut of in-app revenues — and blacklisting developers that don't comply — violates US antitrust law. The suit is viewed as a potential landmark case for antitrust enforcement as well as a possible turning point for the wider digital economy, which runs on app stores.
Based on the evidence in the case so far, Gonzalez Rogers wrote in the order, Epic will face a difficult challenge winning its case on the merits. But she acknowledged that there are 'serious questions' about Apple's business model, and that Apple's attempt to ban Unreal Engine would have had ripple effects across the video game industry.
During a hearing Monday to consider whether the order was necessary, Gonzalez Rogers raised deep doubts about Apple's app store and its effects on competition.
'The problem is, if you have an iPhone, you can't buy [apps] from anyone else,' she said. 'You can't. You are limited to buying it from Apple. I can't buy it from Google. i can't buy it from Amazon. There is no competition. And so the question is, without competition, where does that 30 percent [figure] come from — why isn't it 10, 15, 20?'
Apple responded that consumers enjoy plenty of competition, mainly in the market for smartphone ecosystems such as iOS and Android.
Scrutiny over Apple's app store has rapidly mounted this year as software developers and antitrust investigators in Congress and in Europe have zeroed in on the company's app store policies.
While Apple has maintained that its policies are industry standard and meant to ensure a consistent and secure app experience for consumers, critics say Apple's 30% fee and requirements that all in-app payments be run through Apple's payment channels chill competition.
Welcome to FTW Explains: a guide to catching up on and better understanding stuff going on in the world.Under a temporary restraining order issued by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, Apple must not block Unreal Engine, a major game development software suite owned by Epic, from its app store. Epic declined to comment.
In a statement Tuesday, Apple reiterated its claim that Fortnite's ban could be resolved by Epic itself.
'We agree with Judge Rogers that 'the sensible way to proceed' is for Epic to comply with the App Store guidelines and continue to operate while the case proceeds,' Apple said. 'If Epic takes the steps the judge has recommended, we will gladly welcome Fortnite back onto iOS. We look forward to making our case to the court in September.'
The order resolves what had become a growing concern over the future of video games, film and television ever since Apple and Epic went to court earlier this month.
Unreal Engine is a major design platform used to create lifelike and ultra-realistic computer-generated scenes. It's played a central role in video games including PlayerUnknown's 'Battlegrounds' and 'Borderlands 3,' and has provided the backdrops in TV shows such as Disney's 'The Mandalorian.'
Last week, Apple told Epic that it planned to revoke its ability to distribute the Unreal Engine software on the Apple app store, not merely block players' access to Fortnite.
If Apple were to follow through on its plan, it could hinder developers, film producers and others from getting a critical tool onto Apple devices to create apps and entertainment for consumers, Epic and other developers argued. To bolster its case, Epic submitted a sworn declaration from Microsoft claiming that Apple's plan 'will harm game creators and gamers.'
On Monday, the judge agreed.
If Apple followed through on its Unreal ban, it would lead to 'potential significant damage to both the Unreal Engine platform itself, and to the gaming industry generally, including on both third-party developers and gamers,' Gonzalez Rogers wrote in her order. 'Epic Games and Apple are at liberty to litigate against each other, but their dispute should not create havoc to bystanders.'
The order comes amid a wider legal claim by Epic that Apple's practice of taking a 30% cut of in-app revenues — and blacklisting developers that don't comply — violates US antitrust law. The suit is viewed as a potential landmark case for antitrust enforcement as well as a possible turning point for the wider digital economy, which runs on app stores.
Based on the evidence in the case so far, Gonzalez Rogers wrote in the order, Epic will face a difficult challenge winning its case on the merits. But she acknowledged that there are 'serious questions' about Apple's business model, and that Apple's attempt to ban Unreal Engine would have had ripple effects across the video game industry.
During a hearing Monday to consider whether the order was necessary, Gonzalez Rogers raised deep doubts about Apple's app store and its effects on competition.
'The problem is, if you have an iPhone, you can't buy [apps] from anyone else,' she said. 'You can't. You are limited to buying it from Apple. I can't buy it from Google. i can't buy it from Amazon. There is no competition. And so the question is, without competition, where does that 30 percent [figure] come from — why isn't it 10, 15, 20?'
Apple responded that consumers enjoy plenty of competition, mainly in the market for smartphone ecosystems such as iOS and Android.
Scrutiny over Apple's app store has rapidly mounted this year as software developers and antitrust investigators in Congress and in Europe have zeroed in on the company's app store policies.
While Apple has maintained that its policies are industry standard and meant to ensure a consistent and secure app experience for consumers, critics say Apple's 30% fee and requirements that all in-app payments be run through Apple's payment channels chill competition.
Welcome to FTW Explains: a guide to catching up on and better understanding stuff going on in the world.Fortnite and its parent company Epic Games have never been afraid to shake things up. That's how it became the most popular game in the world today.
Now, they're taking that same attitude that got them there to the doorsteps of two of the biggest tech companies in the world in Apple and Google.
Fortnite mysteriously disappeared from the Apple Store on Thursday without a trace. If users already had the game downloaded to their phones, it was still there. But anyone looking for the game? It was nowhere to be found. Photo download the app.
Come to find out, Apple flatout removed it from the App Store.
A few hours later, it was also banned on Google's Play Store.
Then, shortly after that, Epic Games dropped a commercial on Fortnite and YouTube called 'Nineteen-Eighty-Fortnite' and everything went off the rails.
Fortnight In The App Store
Lost in all the madness? Don't worry. Here's what's happening.
Wait, wait, wait. Why did Apple ban Fortnite?
So on Fortnite, there are these things called V-Bucks. Think of them as virtual tokens you can use to purchase new 'skins' and collectables on the game.
To actually get V-Bucks, though, you pay real life cash. Generally speaking, to this point, about 1,000 V-Bucks cost $9.99 in real life when purchased through the Apple Store or the Google Play store. Until now, those have been the only mediums to purchase them through on mobile platforms.
Fortnite The Application Has Crashed
Until now, anyway. And here's where things get tricky and the beef starts brewing.
Epic Games changed that. They created an in-game direct payment system that charged $7.99 for those same 1,000 V-Bucks instead of $9.99.
So they're saving gamers a couple of dollars?
Yup, exactly. Instead of having them pay for the V-Bucks through Apple's and Google's systems, they give them a better deal in doing it through their own.
Why would they be shut down for that?
Well, it's a problem for Apple and Google as the hosting platforms. This tweet from Esports expert Matthew Ball explains it well.
In exchange for hosting Fortnite on the App Store on the Google Play Store, the platforms review the app for users and charge a 30% commission on in-app purchases.
Epic Game's in-game store circumvents that 30% commission, which Apple and Google say is a violation of the original agreement. So, therefore, they've removed the game.
So as long as this in-app store exists we won't see Fortnite on our phones?
If you don't already have it, no. At least not for iPhones anyway. Fortnite is still available through other app stores on Android systems. Tough luck, iPhone crowd.
Don't worry. Epic Games isn't sitting still, though. They're suing both Googleand Apple for the removal of the game from their platforms. And, the thing is, they clearly expected this to happen.
What do you mean?
Epic Games broke out those lawsuits against both companies shortly after Fortnite was removed from both Google Play and the App Store. They counted on each company taking the actions they did.
Fortnite The App Store
And, as a public response, they dropped a Fortnite-style commercial you might recognize.
This is a clear shot at Apple's famous Super Bowl commercial set in an Orewllian '1984' dystopia from back in the day.
That's feels mad dramatic here, but whatever. You get the point.
What's their purpose in all of this?
Fortnite The App Download
That's the thing — it's hard to really say. They're calling the current system they're working in a 'monopoly,' and they'll battle it out in court to try and prove it.
But, honestly, it just seems like they're trying to skip over paying the commission fee to their current distributors in Apple and Google which…fine.
But they've turned this into a public relations battle and it's hard to tell how much ground they actually have to stand on.
Fortnite The Application Has Crashed
This is weird and complicated.
Very much so. But it's not going anywhere anytime soon. Fortnite fans, you'll want to keep your eyes on this one.